Review 2247: Girls Who Lie

Boys discover a body hidden in a cave on a lava flow. It’s quickly established that it’s the body of Marianna, a woman who has been missing for seven months and has been presumed to have committed suicide. But Marianna was murdered.

When officers Elma and Sævar investigate, they find that Marianna has had periods when her daughter, Hekla, was removed from her care. Now, things seem to be going well, but 15-year-old Hekla spends a lot of time with her foster parents.

Interspersed in the novel is a narrative by a woman containing at times disturbing information. But we don’t know who this narrator is. Is it Marianna or someone else?

This is the second book in this series featuring Elma (last name? first name? Ægisdottir seems always to use just one for all her characters). I have mixed feelings about the series. The plotting is fairly good, and the novel ends in a chilling way. However, the dialogue seems unconvincing, and characterization is minimal. This is the same way I felt about Camilla Lackberg’s novels, so it’s hard to know whether it’s a translation problem (the dialogue, I mean) or the author’s writing ability. I don’t think I’ll be sticking with this series.

Related Posts

The Creak on the Stairs

Gallows Rock

My Soul to Take

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.