I took one of my breaks from reading Les Misérables to read Queen Macbeth for Novellas in November. Historical fiction, Val McDermid, Scotland, another of the Darkland Tales . . . what’s not to like? Well.
The novella is narrated by Gruoch, Lady Macbeth, and is set in two time periods. One is after Macbeth’s death in battle with Malcolm. The other is when Gruoch, the reluctant wife of Gille Coemgáin, who probably plotted with Malcolm to kill Macbeth’s father, meets Macbeth.
After Macbeth’s death, Gruoch is fleeing Malcolm accompanied by her four maids and Angus, her bodyguard. They have been hiding for a while on a small island with a monastery, but now someone has arrived, a scout from Malcolm, and they must escape.
In the earlier timeframe, Gruoch’s maid Eithna, who can see things, implies that childless Gruoch will have a child by Macbeth, despite being married to Gille Coemgáin. Gruoch is attracted to Macbeth and risks their lives to have sex with him, then is in love.
There is no acknowledgment of it, but this book seems to owe a lot to Dorothy Dunnett’s King Hereafter, her story of Macbeth. Not all, because Dunnett makes Macbeth a Viking from the Orkneys who takes the name of Macbeth after his conversion to Christianity. Interestingly, Dunnett says his original name is Thorfinn, and MacDermid has the two meet a cousin Thorfin.
But I have to say I found this novella really disappointing. McDermid can really write a novel, but here, the romance is unconvincing, the dialogue trite, the detail scanty, the characterization almost nonexistent. She doesn’t do enough to make us care for her characters before she has Macbeth trap Coemgáin and his men in a building and set fire to it. Believe me, if you’re going to have a character do something like that, you have to have already got readers on their side.
A trip to Rome, although maybe historically accurate, seems totally out of place. And we won’t even mention the ending, except to say it’s ridiculous.

